feat(irm): Update evaluation logic

2 files changed, 30 insertions, 6 deletions

diff --git a/src/umabot/rules/intelligent_moderator_base.py b/src/umabot/rules/intelligent_moderator_base.py
index 781057a..86acdfe 100644
--- a/src/umabot/rules/intelligent_moderator_base.py
+++ b/src/umabot/rules/intelligent_moderator_base.py
@@ -40,11 +40,26 @@ Guidelines for Art vs In-Character:
 - Posts that describe building, creating, or doing something from a character's perspective should stay In Character even if they show the result
 
 Guidelines for Content Needing Development:
-- Content "needs more development" if it lacks substance, creativity, or meaningful in-character content
-- Consider factors like: word count, creativity, effort, engagement potential, originality
-- Be strict but fair - err on the side of allowing content unless it's clearly brief or lacking development
+- Content "needs more development" ONLY if it's genuinely brief, lacks substance, or has minimal in-character content
+- Consider factors like: word count, creativity, effort, engagement potential, originality, character development
+- Be VERY lenient - err heavily on the side of allowing content unless it's clearly and obviously brief
+- Only remove content that is genuinely low-quality, not just short
 - High confidence (0.8+) for clear cases, lower confidence for borderline cases
 
+Examples of ACCEPTABLE content (should NOT be removed):
+- Character status updates with context and future plans
+- Posts with OOC notes explaining absence or context
+- Character interactions and responses to others
+- Posts that show character personality or development
+- Content that provides meaningful context or storytelling
+- Posts that engage with the community or other characters
+
+Examples of content that NEEDS MORE DEVELOPMENT (should be removed):
+- Single sentence posts with no context
+- Posts that are just "I think..." with no elaboration
+- Content that lacks any meaningful character development
+- Posts that are clearly spam or off-topic
+
 Post to evaluate:
 Title: {title}
 Content: {content}
diff --git a/src/umabot/rules/intelligent_roleplay_moderator.py b/src/umabot/rules/intelligent_roleplay_moderator.py
index a0d29cc..b9bc62f 100644
--- a/src/umabot/rules/intelligent_roleplay_moderator.py
+++ b/src/umabot/rules/intelligent_roleplay_moderator.py
@@ -43,9 +43,18 @@ class IntelligentRoleplayModerator(Rule, IntelligentModeratorBase):
                 return False  # Don't remove, just change flair
             
             elif evaluation["is_low_effort"]:
-                # Remove brief post and notify user
-                self._notify_brief_content_removal(submission, evaluation)
-                return True  # Remove the post
+                # Only remove if confidence is high enough (0.8+)
+                confidence = evaluation.get("confidence", 0.0)
+                if confidence >= 0.8:
+                    # Remove brief post and notify user
+                    self._notify_brief_content_removal(submission, evaluation)
+                    return True  # Remove the post
+                else:
+                    # Low confidence - allow the post
+                    self.logger.info(
+                        f"Post {submission.id} flagged as brief but confidence too low ({confidence:.2f}), allowing post"
+                    )
+                    return False
             
             # Post is good quality roleplay - allow it
             return False